Although watching virtuoso guitarists blaze through fretboards with lightning speed might suggest otherwise, even the greatest musicians are human—and that means they have limitations. David Gilmour, the iconic guitarist of Pink Floyd, is a perfect example of how turning a perceived weakness into an advantage can define an entire musical legacy.
Ever since he joined Pink Floyd in 1967, Gilmour has been candid about his personal challenges as a player. While he may not possess the fast-fingered dexterity of some of his contemporaries, he chose instead to double down on the skills that made him unique—an approach that helped place him among the world’s greatest guitarists and the mastermind behind some of the most memorable solos in rock history.
“I just have not got very good coordination between left and right hand,” Gilmour admitted in a 2002 interview with The Telegraph. “My fingers are very slow. I couldn’t do what all these other guitar players could do, so I had to do something different.”
That “something different” became his hallmark style: crafting soaring, emotional guitar melodies that became integral to Pink Floyd’s sound. One of the most famous examples is his stirring solo in 1979’s “Comfortably Numb”—a piece that showcases not speed, but feel, timing, and emotive phrasing.
In a 2023 conversation with YouTube music educator Rick Beato, Gilmour revisited this theme. “I wasn’t gifted with enormous speed on the guitar,” he said. During his early years, he recalled, he struggled to keep up with his peers and briefly tried to chase their technical prowess. “There were years,” he noted, “when I was younger where I thought I could get that if I practiced enough. But it just wasn’t ever really going to happen. I’ve got no control over the music I make.”
It was during this phase of soul-searching that Gilmour began to examine other guitarists’ approaches, ultimately finding inspiration in a rather unexpected place—not among the flashy soloists like Steve Howe, Steve Hackett, or Jimi Hendrix, but in the smooth stylings of the Shadows’ Hank Marvin.
“Back in the ’60s, Hank was just playing a tune,” Gilmour told Beato. “I think I come from there. I just want to play a nice tune!”
This shift in mindset led him to emphasize melody, space, and tone over sheer technical display. In doing so, Gilmour discovered a new kind of precision—one rooted not in speed, but in expression.
“I’m quite fussy about overeager vibrato,” he said, revealing how even the smallest musical nuances matter to him. “Sometimes a little thing gives it a little extra tone or — I hate to say the word — ‘refinement,’” he added with a self-effacing laugh.
Gilmour’s vibrato, often described as elegant and subtle, has become one of his most defining traits. MusicRadar once analyzed vibrato techniques across legendary guitarists—ranging from B.B. King to Brian May and Zakk Wylde—and concluded that Gilmour’s produced the smoothest sound waves of them all.
“[Gilmour’s] vibrato is smooth, often ethereal, and has a very subtle and slow rise and fall in pitch,” the article noted. “Think B.B. King in super-slow motion.”
Last year, Gilmour released Luck and Strange, his first solo album in nine years. He described the record as the best material he’s written since The Dark Side of the Moon. And although he took a long break between releases, he’s made it clear that he hopes to maintain momentum and put out more music in the near future.
In the end, David Gilmour’s story isn’t one of overcoming a shortcoming by beating it—it’s about embracing what makes him different and using that to forge a unique and timeless sound. He didn’t become a shredder. He became a storyteller. And millions of fans around the world are glad he did.
Related Topics
- Marty Friedman: Speed Isn’t Everything — “Music Needs Meaning, Not Just Flash”
- Country Star Chris Young Gifts Gibson Guitar After Airline Destroys Musician’s Instrument
- Paul McCartney Pays Tribute to Jeff Beck: “No One Could Match His Unique Style”
