Learning to play the guitar is a journey that many musicians embark on, with different approaches leading to varying results. Among the many methods available, one that stands out is learning by playing songs. The question often arises: Is it better to learn guitar by learning songs? To answer this, we need to explore the benefits and drawbacks of this method, compare it with other learning techniques, and determine how effective it is for beginners, intermediates, and even seasoned players looking to expand their skills.
The Basics of Learning Guitar
Before diving into whether learning by songs is the best approach, it’s essential to understand the basics of learning the guitar. The guitar, a versatile string instrument, has been a staple in many musical genres, from rock and blues to jazz and classical. For beginners, learning guitar often starts with mastering basic chords, strumming techniques, and finger placement. More advanced players dive into intricate techniques, scales, and theory.
Traditional Learning Methods
Traditional learning methods generally involve starting with basic music theory, note reading, and scale practice. With time, players begin to apply these lessons by learning songs. This structured approach, whether through private lessons or online courses, emphasizes technical proficiency and understanding the fundamentals.
Learning Songs as a Method
In contrast, learning by playing songs means jumping straight into real-world applications of the instrument. It’s about using a familiar piece of music as a vehicle to gain practical skills. This method tends to bypass some formal learning to focus directly on playing, often through tutorials or tablature, and can involve tackling chords, rhythm patterns, and even soloing. But the question is: does this approach yield better results?
Why Learning Guitar by Songs is Effective
1. Motivation and Enjoyment
One of the most compelling reasons to learn guitar by learning songs is the level of motivation it provides. For many people, the ultimate goal of learning an instrument is to be able to play the songs they love. Whether it’s a favorite rock anthem, a heartfelt acoustic ballad, or a jazz standard, playing a song brings immediate joy and a sense of accomplishment.
The guitar is a popular instrument for beginners, and the ease with which one can start playing simple versions of their favorite tunes is highly motivating. From a psychological standpoint, this form of “instant gratification” is key to keeping new players engaged. It’s not uncommon for students to feel frustrated with traditional methods, but when they begin playing their first recognizable song, the excitement to continue practicing grows significantly.
2. Practical Application
Learning to play songs on the guitar allows for a more direct application of the skills being developed. Instead of focusing solely on abstract concepts, students are applying techniques to real music right from the start. This immediate use of knowledge can reinforce lessons and make theory seem more tangible.
For example, a beginner might start with basic open chords like C, G, and D. As they learn these chords, they can apply them to songs like “Wonderwall” by Oasis or “Knockin’ on Heaven’s Door” by Bob Dylan. These songs use simple chord progressions, but mastering them allows the learner to see immediate progress, reinforcing their understanding and technique.
3. Understanding Musical Context
When you learn guitar through songs, you’re exposed to various musical contexts. This approach helps students understand rhythm, phrasing, and timing, all of which are crucial to musical expression. While scales and exercises can be essential to technical growth, learning songs places these technical skills within a musical framework, helping students understand how notes and chords interact within a song structure.
For example, playing a chord progression like I-IV-V (a common structure in blues, rock, and country) teaches students about harmony and how different chords work together to create musical tension and release. Playing solos, on the other hand, provides insights into melody, expression, and phrasing.
4. Building a Repertoire
Learning songs is an excellent way to build a repertoire of music that can be used for performance or jamming with others. For guitarists, having a handful of well-known songs in your arsenal is a powerful tool. It helps develop versatility and the ability to adapt to various musical genres.
Building a repertoire is especially beneficial for aspiring performers. Guitarists who can confidently play songs in front of an audience are more likely to gain performance experience early on, which is essential for musicians aiming to develop stage presence and musical interaction with other players.
5. Hands-on Learning and Memory Retention
One significant advantage of learning through songs is how it improves memory retention. When students play a song repeatedly, they memorize the finger positions, chord changes, and rhythms. Over time, this hands-on learning embeds these elements into muscle memory, which can be far more effective than rote memorization of theory or scales alone.
Songs often have repeating structures, which can further cement these concepts into the player’s mind. For example, learning a song like “Twinkle Twinkle Little Star” on guitar involves memorizing just a few simple chords and repeating them throughout the song, helping the learner focus on execution without worrying about learning too many new things.
6. Access to a Large Body of Knowledge
Songs come with a built-in structure and often rely on common chord progressions, making them a great resource for learning a wide variety of techniques. By learning different songs, players will become familiar with a broad range of chord progressions, strumming patterns, and even fingerstyle techniques. Each song offers a new lesson in how guitar is used in different genres and styles of music, providing valuable exposure to various musical traditions.
7. Effective for Group Learning
For beginners, learning songs can also make group learning or jamming easier. In group lessons, students are often encouraged to play together, creating a sense of community and teamwork. Since songs are a shared interest, learning them in a group context fosters collaboration, and players learn how to interact with one another musically.
Drawbacks of Learning Guitar by Songs
While learning guitar through songs is an engaging and enjoyable approach, it is not without its drawbacks.
1. Limited Technical Growth
One of the major criticisms of learning through songs is that it can limit a player’s technical development. Songs often focus on specific techniques or patterns, but they don’t necessarily provide the depth required for more advanced guitar skills. If students only learn songs, they may not gain a comprehensive understanding of the underlying theory, scales, and techniques that are necessary to progress as musicians.
For example, while learning a song might teach a beginner to play barre chords, it won’t necessarily teach them how to build those chords from the ground up or understand how they fit into the key of the song. As a result, students may struggle with improvisation or more complex pieces of music in the future.
2. Risk of Rote Learning
In some cases, learning songs can lead to rote learning, where students memorize specific songs without fully understanding the mechanics behind them. This can create a barrier for those who want to branch out into more complex music or develop their improvisational skills.
If students do not make an effort to understand music theory, chord construction, or scale patterns, they may reach a point where they feel stuck, unable to progress beyond the songs they have learned.
3. Song Choices May Be Limited
The songs chosen to learn may not always align with a student’s musical interests or goals. A beginner might feel unmotivated if the songs they are learning don’t resonate with them or if the songs are too difficult to play at their skill level.
Additionally, the guitar world is full of diverse genres and techniques, and focusing on a specific genre or artist’s songs can limit a player’s exposure to the vast array of styles that guitar has to offer.
Comparing Learning by Songs vs. Traditional Methods
The traditional approach to learning guitar—starting with technical exercises, scales, and theory—offers a more structured way of building a solid foundation. In contrast, learning by playing songs provides a more practical, immediately rewarding experience.
For beginners, starting with songs can make the learning process less intimidating and more engaging. It can offer a sense of achievement earlier on, which can be encouraging. However, as players advance, they may find that a deeper understanding of theory and technique is essential for taking their skills to the next level.
In the long term, a balance of both approaches is often the most beneficial. Learning songs gives immediate gratification and helps solidify the practical application of skills, while traditional methods can deepen one’s technical understanding and musical vocabulary.
Conclusion
So, is it better to learn guitar by learning songs? The answer depends on the learner’s goals and the stage of their musical journey. For beginners, learning songs offers immediate engagement and practical application that can accelerate motivation and enjoyment. However, for more advanced players, it’s essential to integrate more traditional learning methods to ensure comprehensive musical development.
Ultimately, a hybrid approach that combines the fun of learning songs with the discipline of mastering technique and theory might be the most effective route. By playing songs, you gain real-world experience, but by continuing to refine your technical and theoretical knowledge, you create a solid foundation for more advanced musical expression. As with any musical instrument, learning guitar is a personal journey, and finding the right balance between enjoyment and technical growth is key to success.
Related Topics
- Yamaha vs Fender: Which Guitar Is Better?
- How Scales Work on Guitar
- How Much is a Yamaha Electric Guitar?
